Started off good but eventually becomes boring. The MC spends way too long hunting and creating new monsters so that it feels more like a video game walkthrough than a novel. And the reuse of monsters is pretty low even if they have ways to become stronger. Even side characters get completely forgotten for hundreds of chapters. Lots of potential but ultimately flops.

Boring. Not bad, actually kind of cool. But this is more like a wizard novel than cultivation. This has the unfortunate effect of making everything take so long. By the time anything happens I've basically stopped caring about it.

Did the author write this with a gun to his head? Randomly in the novel it pivots between your typical infinite reincarnation novel, and other times it's written as absolutely no fantasy here no sir wink wink. I'm so confused.

Well written and entertaining. Only 3 stars because a lot of chapters are missing near the end

Too much water and repetition.

I really think this should rate higher although it does have issues. It feels like it gets more boring as it progresses honestly. I found his sister to be kind of annoying which isn't great considering how often she's around. It eventually becomes more about maintaining the harem than anything which kind of sucks.

Really enjoyed it early on but the later it went the less I liked it. Wizards don't use spells, just their innate abilities? Why make them wizards then? As it progressed it became less like a wizard novel and more like a Lord novel. Make an army, conquer resources, make another army, recruit people, repeat. I had high hopes but it became kinda meh for me.

A solid read. Funny interactions and a MC who isn't too OP. His personality really fits the One Piece world too.

Just a cheap rip off of a better (originally) novel

So, this one is actually a good one. Kind of politics and intrigue heavy though. And the story kind of jumps around a lot so it can be hard to get into. Definitely worth reading.