well up until the end of lower realm in my opinion this is 100/100 novel but after upper realm just like most other novel it start to go bad at the beginning cuz mc act like the original book protag which is kinda turn off for me. maybe i will continue finishing this after resting for sometime to rest my mind from the way mc act after ascending. Overall plot-10/10 character depth-7/10 cheat-7.4/10 side character/fml-8/10 mc personality-lower realm 10/10 upper realm-?/10 story progression-9/10 Overall if you”re looking for serious and comedy xuanhuan novel this is the one. Not your typical brainless villain mc,pervert,jade collector and so on. the mc depth and his personality build up is there which make it more original than typical edgy transmigration mc villain trope.

downside- even tho the fmc live 1000 years with the mc but the mc doesn’t retain most of the memories making their interaction force and 1 sided love without reason from mc prespective goodside-atleast the mc isn’t somekind of pervert or hypocrite even tho he is not a villain either. not recomended unless you are new reader

the mc is too forced on the book plot that makes it like the mc doesn’t have his own personality

i don’t know when it will get better so 3 star is enough although i would give it lower just cuz the mc is wimp eventho he already live 9 lives. after finishing this - the mc still a wimp and simp from start to finish if only the mc was decent this might get a slightly high rating. story wise is very average

read all the chaps the beginning may not suit some people but later the plot thicken more and more and the plot twist can’t even be guess. and actually this has a solid foundation of story with early plot coming later for later event. mc rise from bottom not just op suddenly in 10 chapters. but around 300-400 chaps the story start getting rushed and then chap 500 it started normal again

not bad it has strong plot point and clear goal. not too much nonsense but funny

tbh this is like a chinese cdrama tteotm

i think a solid 2.9 is good enough. this stroy is very fast pace so the plot are a bit jumbling but if your looking for typical villain trope then this is it

one of its kind you will never see the same characters in any novel any other than this the way all member of mc second sect become very blood headed was very good