Too lazy to describe in detail, but for those who want to read this then I can only say this is bad.

Lacking in many areas.

Its good, not my taste but good enough. MC is good too, not too much nor too little.

Oh my god, this is good, REALLY GOOD! No rush, good flow, logical decisions, controlled plot development, no extreme arrogant personality, remembers past life but adapts to current one but not completely abandoning previous morality. All in all, an awesome cyberpunk 2077 fanfic and the others as well!

Ok story is really bad for me, not just the late part of the story but even near the start. What was it again? The Abnormal Gillian! Is author so uncreative that after the MC just entered Heuco Mundo and became a hollow, he encountered a very abnormal gillian that can use flash steps and having a very high IQ... Wow! Just wow! Even the next chapter after... sheesh!

Wonderful! Finished it and it was great! Too bad the fanfiction ends after finishing all the bad guys and attaining peace, can't see our MC develop an entire civilization towards the sea of stars.

A great story, I like it!

Lol, this MC is a 100% arrogant dude similar to xianxia protagonist, even after understanding the SIM shows the future, he still choose dumb choices and rash decisions, along the way their is no development as well. Straight strength growth of the MC is like riding on a rocket! Boring as heck!

Okay, this is bad, very bad, why is it always like this, an MC in a normal anime daily-life world suddenly becomes supernatural, then BOOM! Their cheat appears and makes them super strong at the start, no development or anything, no hardships or lesson learned by the MC, just straight power-up just because author says so. The author just wanted to fulfill their lame dreams, another bad story being dumped here in this website.

Great story really, it goes beyond the movie of the hobbit and expands the scope of the story to the entire continent, involving the unsaid wizards, kingdoms, forces, magic, etc. I like it very much that SAURON is not the end boss, but just one among many powerful beings in middle-earth, as well as telling a bit of the outer gods beyond the realm. Really like fanfictions like these that expand the story beyond the movie. Especially there isn't 'world hopping' going on, I like this that the author is focusing the development in one world, why add other movies and animes? This is good enough. Though I'm wondering, is the MC ever gonna get married? Like have a wife and kids? That would make this more wholesome.